Ispot.tv put together an interesting breakdown of the top 20 Super Bowl Commercials (2015) by digital activity on game day (online plays and social media actions). We take it one step further and calculate the ratio of online views to social media actions: Lost Dog (Budweiser) 13.77:1 Data Stash/Kim Kardashian (T-mobile) 27.27:1 Revenge/Liam Neeson (Supercell - Clash of Clans mobile game) 146:1 Pay With Lovin' (McDonald's) 14.66:1 Like a Girl (Always) 5.13:1 Real-life Pac Man (Bud Light) 32.65:1 Brady Bunch (Snickers) 42.55:1 Big Game (Coca-cola) 29.06:1 Blue Pill (Fiat) .67:1 Super Bowl Apology (Sprint) 1.05:1 Data Stash/Sarah Silverman, Chelsea Handler (T-mobile) 3.76:1 Microsoft (Brilliant Bus) 36:1 Make Safe Happen (Nationwide Insurance) 5.23:1 Wisdom (Dodge) .35:1 Newfangled Idea (BMW) 520:1 Fable (Mercedes-Benz) 150:1 Braylon O'Neill (Microsoft) 8.56:1 Real Strength (Dove) 5.89:1 With Dad (Nissan) 2.35:1 911 Delivery (Joyful Heart Foundation) 26.81:1 | New Rankings (according to the ratio of online views to social media action: Wisdom (Dodge) .35:1 Blue Pill (Fiat) .67:1 Super Bowl Apology (Sprint) 1.05:1 With Dad (Nissan) 2.35:1 Data Stash/Sarah Silverman, Chelsea Handler (T-mobile) 3.76:1 Like a Girl (Always) 5.13:1 Make Safe Happen (Nationwide Insurance) 5.23:1 Real Strength (Dove) 5.89:1 Braylon O'Neill (Microsoft) 8.56:1 Lost Dog (Budweiser) 13.77:1 Pay With Lovin' (McDonald's) 14.66:1 911 Delivery (Joyful Heart Foundation) 26.81:1 Data Stash/Kim Kardashian (T-mobile) 27.27:1 Big Game (Coca-cola) 29.06:1 Real-life Pac Man (Bud Light) 32.65:1 Microsoft (Brilliant Bus) 36:1 Brady Bunch (Snickers) 42.55:1 Revenge/Liam Neeson (Supercell - Clash of Clans mobile game) 146:1 Fable (Mercedes-Benz) 150:1 Newfangled Idea (BMW) 520:1 |
Of course, these numbers aren't fully representative of the long term effect (sales generated, etc.) of the ads listed. Nor do they [according to us] represent the entertainment value of the ads listed. However, in an on-demand world they do represent how well advertisers did in terms of capturing a viewer's attention during the big game. They do represent how well advertisers were able to inspire action. It appears that Supercell, Mercedes-Benz, and BMW could have done a much better job of reaching would-be consumers
Just a thought...